(submitted by Hayley)
Hi andy! Now looking at what you written I have a different view n the picture now. It’s very humbling to hear that you and your family are all happy and that you were brought up in the right way…..the trouble is, there’s no harmony in this world and people tend to twist things and turn them round into something ugly and then dismiss it and shove it in a dark place where no one can look. Such a nice world ey!! I hope your brothers are ok they look happy on the picture. X Louise.
The pro water birthers need to settle down on here. Yelling at anyone that doesn’t find the family water birth experience ideal is just as bad as the people calling this nasty. To each their own. Some people think this is the most magical thing, while others would prefer that their little ones out of the room. But the choice will be made based on how one’s family will handle the situation.
However I think the picture is cute, everyone looks happy minus the blonde kid on the left. He looks like he has mixed feelings on the ordeal.
If everyone think it’s normal, why is it posted in awkward family photo’s?
At first I too thought there was kool aide or something in the water for the entertainment of the kids. Until I saw the newborn of course. I love this picture. I am pregnant now with my third and have been considering the idea of letting my older children stay in the room. I think it is a beautiful thing witnessing the birth of a child. I also think its a good way to show your other children how much you love them and that you want to share that experience with them. To anyone who sees this picture as anything but beautiful I say shame on you. How do you think our ancestors brought life into this world? Not in a hospital while the other children were at the sitters. My grandmothers oldest daughter witnessed all of her siblings births though some she can’t remember from being too young at the time. It wasn’t shunned upon them and shouldn’t be now.
Who are you to judge ones morals, morals are just as unique to one person as a finger print. No two people have the exact same morals. They might be similar but not identicle. That’s like saying someone isn’t “normal.” Can anyone giver a definition of normal? What is normal? What is right or wrong. Or do we all just believe what the government and churches tell us is right or wrong or moralistic or normal.
I wanted my son to be there for the birth of his brother and he chose not to ( He was 3 1/2 and we left it up to him). As I may not chose to have my children in the water, there is nothing wrong with these parents letting their children be a part of their siblings birth. As you can see from the picture these are loving parents who actually care about their children and want them involved, better than deadbeats who have kids and pawn them off on other people right? I have to be honest the thought of anyone else being in water with my blood and afterbirth, really grosses me out. For their safety and mine. However the sight of loving parents and happy children is beautiful. And Mama looks fantastic! I hope your family is forever this happy and wish you all the best of luck
I dont get it…what are they…..wait….whoa….WHOA…..AAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
My thoughts EXACTLY!!
To each his/her own. My own ick factor came out but they look happy so who are we to judge?
Who ever says this is not awkward, is awkward
I seriously just lol’d!
Took me a moment to get it. Then I thought this was one of the most amazing things I’ve ever seen in my life. My nieces/nephews were water births and attended the younger one’s births when they happened. I’ve never known such loving, close siblings. They experience the arrival of another living being. It’s incredible. Looking at this picture I could tell you this must be a close loving family. Then I read the comments of Andy who said it was his birth and confirmed it. This is incredible. Sharing the birth of a loved one, and being a part of it in this level of intimacy is something that could never be paralleled anywhere in a person’s life. This is a closeness that I think every human should have a chance to understand. We would never have war.
I’m actually the newborn in this photo, 23 years old now. I was the first water birth and home birth in our family, with three after me. After the traumatic hospital births, which were physically damaging to my mother and life risking to my brothers, and after the cold way the hospitals handled her miscarriages, it was a beautiful relief for her to experience such an easy birth at home without complication, with less pain and more beauty for mother and child, and for their family, too. It was something everyone was so happy about.
We lived in a nudist camp in those days. Nudity wasn’t anything shameful or erotic or gross to us. It was a beautiful way to try to live. Only a couple years after my birth, my parents left the nudist camp. We all lead a pretty normal life today, no therapy was required for anyone after the birth, ha, and a good shower solved all.
I don’t really mind that you’ve all made a spectacle of my birth. It was wrong of you, to make yourselves gossips and judges like that, but whatever, I get it. This photo did get around my little sister’s high school today, though, and some of her friends told people it is her family in the photo. A lot of people in the school were talking about it, and today was really hard for her. She wasn’t really embarrassed; she was just hurt. And she had a hard time understanding why people would be so petty.
My parents have shown us great love over the years, a love you can see in this photo, and we have passed on that love to each other and to others. I’m thankful for it. Sadly, though, that love is not normal in the world. I wish it were. Then more of you would know it and understand. And then my sister wouldn’t have had such a hard day.
Good for you Andy, for being such a strong person to write your comment. Wo cares what everyone else thinks!
I absolutely love this picture. More than average of the comments on here seem to be supportive. I hope your little sister can learn to realize that people may be judgmental, but she can be better than that.
That’s a really beautiful, happy, healing moment for your mother and family. Beautiful!
Hi Andy – I’m so glad you posted and I’m sorry that the publication of this photo (or, rather, the comments that you found hurtful) upset you.
To be fair, there is quite a lot of blood in the bath and not everyone feels comfortable with that – it’s a natural human instinct to be afraid of blood, isn’t it? I had a boyfriend who was incredibly squeamish about me menstruating and I actually found that hurtful and offensive as well as he always made such a big deal about it.
Anyway, your family look so happy and that’s the most important thing.
Yay! I’m so glad that your mom got to have a peaceful birth and that she shared it with her family. Theses are tears of joy, darn it!
Hi Andy, Nice letter. Sounds like your family life was a happy one so that is the most important….maybe it will give more close minded people something to ponder. I hope your sister can get through the high school talk. I can imagine it will be difficult…kids can be very mean when they do not want to understand other lifestyles. I hope she gets lots of support and it blows over.
Andy, I thought someone dumped coke into the tub, then I saw the newborn and though”WHOA.” I question the whole family in the tub idea, but I’m a nurse I understand how important it is to families to be there when a new baby come to our world. I am truely sorry how hard it was for your sister to go to school and have others make fun of her and your family. Many blessings to you and your close family.
There are more positive comments here than negative. Andy, for THAT, I am glad for you. I was bullied as a kid in middle and high school. It just plain sucks when other kids get their kicks making others feel “less than”. I hope the backlash at your sister’s school ended quickly.
Your family made a decision that was best for them. My only (personal) issue was with your siblings being in the water. I can just barely understand your dad being in the water. But, like I said, that’s MY hangup. I think that’s where the negative comments are rooted.
I think water births are such a wonderful option for mothers. What a gift your family had, after pregnancy and birthing difficulties, being able to bring you into the world in a peaceful birth.
You are truly an understanding and patient person (both phenomenal qualities) to have written such a positive reply in this thread. I wish you well.
What a wonderful, straightforward, caring, non-judgmental comment from an obviously mature, well-adjusted young man who cares deeply about his family.
To the rest of us it’s awkward, to him it is his life and he is neither ashamed, embarrassed nor angry at those poking fun. We need more people like that in this world, regardless of their birth story.
I was thinking about the rest of the family’s exposure to the bodily fluids of mom and baby, but you’re right – those kids are probably more likely to cause the infection.
Disturbing? Are you serious? What is wrong here, omg get some morals and values before you have anymore babies!!
Really? You think it’s immoral to share the birth of a child? Who left you in charge or morality? I think the values of a mother giving birth in a way that she feels is safe and loving and physically easier is very loving and moral. So there’s some blood in the water – big deal. They’ll all shower and have an amazing experience to share while you live in your very uptight and judgmental world!
Mail (will not be published) (required)